Opponents argue that under Amendment L, 41% of voters could block the majority. But “the voters” in that argument means those who cast ballots, not all registered voters. In an election with 64% turnout, as it was in our last presidential election, a constitutional amendment can currently pass with support from 32% of registered voters. At a 60% threshold, it would take about 38.4%.

Neither represents a majority of all registered voters, but Amendment L requires broader consensus before changing our foundational document.

logo

Subscribe to The Dakota Scout to read the rest of the story.

Become a paying subscriber of The Dakota Scout to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Subscribe

A subscription gets you:

  • Daily news in your inbox
  • Viewpoints, concert reviews, obituaries
  • Weekly digital copy of print version

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Bridget Knapper1 month ago

Brilliantly written and articulated, Taffy! This is a simple step to prevent American Marxism from continuing to take it's hold in South Dakota, and the far left knows it. Thank you John Hughes for authoring Amendment L. Please vote yes!

Avatar

Dean Nasser1 month ago(edited)

I’m sorry but although I want L to pass if you are voting for it so the right can divide itself further from the left à la Trump you are voting for it for ignoble and impure reasons. Please urge unity in SD not further division. L is to protect everyone from movements gaining traction that harm both poles on the political spectrum and all points min the middle. L is to protect all of us. It’s NOT an us vs them.

Avatar

Not a pinhead1 month ago

Spot on Taffy. All crazies ate looking any way to weaken and destroy this country.

Avatar

The Heart of Everything1 month ago

"In an election with 64% turnout, as it was in our last presidential election, a constitutional amendment can currently pass with support from 32% of registered voters.” The fact that so many fail to perform their civic duty is a different issue—Republicans reverse this argument when it suits them—we’re told when a minority of Republicans choose candidates that those who show up get to choose. Okay, same deal. If 32 percent vote and 51% of those choose to make a constitutional change, deal with it. A simple majority of legislators gets to put a constitutional amendment on the ballot—no signatures required, no lengthy or thorough debate of pros and cons, just the same political wind blowing in a caucus that’s closed to the public without the input of South Dakotans who have to live with the consequences. Vote No.

Avatar

Dean Nasser1 month ago

Heart, I respectfully disagree. That logic is OK for a statute, but when they are taking away you basic rights in a Constitution that 32% makes no sense.

Avatar

Michael L. Wyland1 month ago

From the op-ed: "The more fundamental and serious the decision, the broader the consensus should be." Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan (D-NY) attempted unsuccessfully to make this argument with President Clinton in 1993 with regard to healthcare reform ("Hillarycare"). His quote, paraphrased, was that the truly important things in politics require a 70% majority. He was almost certainly referring primarily to the U.S. Senate, but I remember the quote being more broadly applicable.

Avatar

Kathy Tyler1 month ago

This is a problem the legislature created. People voted for referred laws. The legislature overturned those votes. People then had to refer issues as constitutional amendments. That way the legislature couldn't overturn the wishes of the people. Start listening and there wouldn't be this problem. No on L.

Avatar

Beth Hughes1 month ago

Examples please

Avatar

Kathy Tyler1 month ago(edited)

The two went back and forth on whether the Republican majorities in the Legislature and the Republican governors in recent years have tried to overrule initiatives which South Dakota voters passed.

As examples, Ahlers listed Medicaid expansion, which Farmers Union helped pass and Republicans are now trying to force out of the South Dakota Constitution; minimum wage, which Republicans tried to override; and legalization of recreational marijuana, which Noem as governor succeeded in having the South Dakota Supreme Court overturn.

Avatar

Dean Nasser1 month ago

Kathy you are completely correct in pointing out that the legislature has in the past had the audacity to overturn the will of the people in the very next legislative session following an initiated measure and that the Governor backed the repeal. (readers, just google: "examples of SD legislature overturning an initiated or referred law"); however, to me at least, what makes no sense when that is your concern is voting "no" on L. At least with Constitutional Amendments, the proposed requirement in L that a 60% "ratification" of both initiated and referred laws would help to insulate the will of the people from legislative meddling should they propose to eliminate of lessen our rights. Without 60%, the legislative deprivation would fail. Much easier for legislative meddling to achieve a 50% than a 60% ratification. I really think the best solution to your concern (and it is mine also) is a "YES" vote on L.

Avatar

Kathy Tyler1 month ago

True, but we are losing the purpose of the constitution. Medicare expansion, marijuana usage are not constitutional issues. (This is probably a vote yes argument!) But we are missing the purpose of a constitution as an outline of how an institution should be run, not the individual laws. Start electing the honest people....

Avatar

Henry Travers1 month ago

I agree with Howard’s premise: in general foundational documents should require a higher requirement of voter agreement for amendment. There are circumstances in South Dakota, though, that substantially weaken that premise. First, the state’s constitution is substantially different from the shorter US Constitution and has many odd provisions as Fiksdal point out. Second is the perfidy of the South Dakota Legislature, its members often placing their personal judgements above the voters. Finally, the voters of South Dakota trust themselves more than they trust the legislature. Amendment L should be rejected and the voters should send a clear message to the legislature to quit cluttering their ballots with questions already decided not once, but twice.

Avatar

John Fiksdal1 month ago

Uh, gee … MOST constitutional amendments already FAIL. Even “housekeeping” amendments put forth by the Legislature. And … “foundational”? Sorry, that horse left the barn decades ago.

Unlike the US Constitution, ours is filled with ephemeral policies. Land use, trust fund management, drugs, interest rates and more—stuff that will likely need to be adjusted over time. At 60%, we’d be stuck with outdated policy.

L is just another swipe by the single-party Legislature to stop citizen-initiated measures. Our ONLY opportunity to pass ideas that encourage equitable economic progress. Don’t just vote NO.

Vote L NO!

Avatar

Dean Nasser1 month ago

John, respectfully, by voting "No" only the least important part of the picture is being considered. A constitutional provision is a "guarantee". We often refer to them as being "Guaranteed by the Constitution". A constitutional "change" is often a deprivation or elimination of the people's "guaranteed rights" even when phrased in terms of a guarantee for the smaller group pushing the "change". Constitutional "changes" often threaten to eliminate, burden, or lessen your guaranteed rights or those of the people you love or to make those lives more precarious or difficult, or to destroy some moral principle. Would you then be wishing that a very slight majority (not of total voters but only those voting on the matter) couldn't get away with destroying such guarantees and that it took 60% of those voting. Amendment L presents the issue of whether the people retain the Power to PROTECTING our rights from deprivation especially from the influences of outside interference.

Avatar

John Cunningham1 month ago

Another terrible idea from our legislators. She’s one of them.

Avatar

John Cunningham1 month ago

Absolutely false. No wonder they call you laffy taffy. Those who voted are those who care. A minority should not rule over the majority. You were elected by a minority of registered voters in your district. Does that mean you should not represent the district?