The Dakota Scout

The Dakota Scout

Judge dismisses libel case vs. Mitchell Republic for publishing Legion baseball demands

Summary judgment granted ‘because the contents of the letter were true’

Patrick Lalley's avatar
Patrick Lalley
Aug 13, 2026
∙ Paid

MITCHELL — A libel and defamation lawsuit against two regional media outlets brought by a former member of the Mitchell American Legion baseball team, embroiled in three years of legal challenges related to a hazing incident, has been dismissed.

Peyton Mandel claimed that Forum Communications — the parent company of the Mitchell Republic — and KELO-TV’s owner, Nextar Media, permanently damaged his reputation and economic prospects by printing a letter from American Legion Adjunct C.P. Van Delist to the Mitchell Baseball Association last year.

Circuit Court Judge David Knoff on Thursday, Aug. 6, granted summary judgment to the media companies, effectively dismissing the libel claims against Forum and Nextar.

SCOUTING YESTERDAY | Adopt-A-Highway sparks civil rights controversy in South Dakota

SCOUTING YESTERDAY | Adopt-A-Highway sparks civil rights controversy in South Dakota

Dan Gehlsen
·
8:38 PM
Read full story
User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of The Dakota Scout.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
Patrick Lalley's avatar
A guest post by
Patrick Lalley
Patrick Lalley is the editor of Sioux Falls Live. plalley@siouxfallslive.com
Subscribe to Patrick
© 2026 The Dakota Scout · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture