The Dakota Scout

The Dakota Scout

Sioux Falls

Democrats find hope in Smith's narrow defeat in Sioux Falls mayoral race

His concession frustrates some in party, but leaders say four-vote margin in South Dakota's largest city shows potential for future races

Joe Sneve's avatar
Dominik Dausch's avatar
Joe Sneve and Dominik Dausch
Jul 19, 2026
∙ Paid
Jamie Smith greets supporters on July 14 following the announcement that he would not challenge the recount results in the race for Sioux Falls mayor, won by four votes by Christine Erickson. (Patrick Lalley / Sioux Falls Live)

Democrats are disappointed. But they’re also encouraged.

Jamie Smith’s four-vote loss in the Sioux Falls mayoral race was a painful reminder of how difficult it remains for Democrats to win major offices in South Dakota. But it also marked the closest a Democratic candidate has come to capturing the mayor’s office in nearly two decades — a sign party leaders say proves their candidates can still compete in the state’s largest city.

The mixed emotions were on display after Smith conceded the race this week, four weeks after finishing behind Mayor-elect Christine Erickson in the June 23 runoff. A recount expanded Erickson’s margin from two votes to four, but the narrow result also sparked frustration among some Democrats who wanted Smith to pursue a legal challenge over rejected absentee ballots.

Thousands of new voters join South Dakota GOP ahead of gubernatorial runoff

Thousands of new voters join South Dakota GOP ahead of gubernatorial runoff

Jonathan Ellis
·
Jul 18
Read full story
User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of The Dakota Scout.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 The Dakota Scout · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture